Following in the footsteps of Howard Zinn.

Years ago on my way home from work while sitting on a light rail commuter train, the woman sitting next to me saw I was reading Howard Zinn’s A People’s History of the United States. Originally published in 1980, by the time I was reading it the book had already achieved a kind of cult status, thanks to Zinn’s efforts to use the book as a readable and fascinating vehicle to promote what he saw as the neglected, forgotten and suppressed history of America: chiefly the political and social struggles of oppressed and/or marginalized individuals such as women, people of color, progressives, the poor and indigenous populations. Seeing me reading A People’s History of the United States, the woman immediately commented to me, “that’s an excellent book !”, elaborated on how much she liked it and before I knew it, rushed off the train as we arrived at her assumed stop. While I never saw her again, I always remembered how a book, especially a powerful one, can bridge the gap between two complete strangers.

So I guess it really shouldn’t be anyone’s surprise that when I saw the book A People’s History of Christianity: The Other Side of the Story sitting on the shelf at the public library I grabbed it with little hesitation. Written by Diane Butler Bass, an Episcopalian by affiliation who has taught at a number of institutions including UC Santa Barbara, Westmont College and Virginia Theological Seminary, A People’s History of Christianity much like its near namesake did 40 years ago with approachable language and style chronicles the forgotten history of those individuals and movements from outside the traditional power centers. And just like Zinn’s book, I liked it.

The book’s purpose is two-fold. According to Butler Bass, by chronicling 2000 plus years of the neglected underside of Christian history, she can show liberal Protestants, who might be lacking an overall knowledge of Church history, that their progressive and humanitarian actions are good and noble, and quite consistent with the actions of many Christians throughout history. For the conservatives, Butler Bass can challenge their reluctance to engage in progressive activities by showing them the same historical examples of Christians nobly following the Great Commandment to “love thy neighbor”.

To do this Butler Bass draws from the deep well of Church history, from the egalitarianism and charity of the persecuted early Church to the radical mystics and pietists of the Middle Ages. From the Reformation to America’s Great Awakening to the Abolitionist movement to the birth of liberal Protestantism’s “Social Gospel”, Diana Butler Bass chronicles the contributions of progressive and radical Christians and their efforts to build a better world.

While I did enjoy this book, much like Howard Zinn’s I would consider it less a history book and more a commentary on history, but at the same time a very worthy supplementary text to a more scholarly study of Church history. Speaking of religious history, in 2011 I plan on being quite immersed in it. As I write this Williston Walker’s classic A History of the Christian Church, Robert Wright’s The Evolution of God, Karen Armstrong’s The Case For God and Diarmaid MacCulloch’s Christianity: The First Three Thousand Years are all sitting next to each other on my desk waiting to be read. Hopefully, after it’s all said and done,  A People’s History of Christianity will have served as a nice supplementary book to that above mentioned formidable quartet.

 

Advertisements

11 Comments

Filed under Christianity, History

11 responses to “Following in the footsteps of Howard Zinn.

  1. Eva

    I’ve been reading more about Christianity lately, and this has definitely peaked my interest! I look forward to your reviews of the books you’re planning on reading too. 🙂

    (Also, I read Zinn’s book years ago. I was reading it in a cafe, and a random woman came over to ask me about it! Must be that kind of book.)

    • Thanks ! I hope to review a few more Christianity-related books before the end of the year as well.
      Perhaps you are right, maybe Zinn’s book IS that kinda book !

  2. This is definitely a book I’d like to read. And I am very curious about next year! I think I need more Karen Armstrong in my life. so I’m hoping you can inspire me 🙂

  3. Wow great combination of books. I’ll be watching for your reviews. I think you are right that this book might be better alongside more scholarly works like the ones you mention.

    • Thanks !
      It’s a rather enjoyable read. Give it a shot sometime !
      To risk sounding like an expert (believe me, I’m not !), here’s a list of five books. I’ve recommended these books to folks who might be questioning or at least have questions about what they were taught growing up in a traditionally-minded Christian environment. Since I can’t think of anything better, I’ll call the list “God, Christianity and the Bible in a deeper historical context”.

      1. God: A Biography by Jack Miles
      2. A History of God by Karen Armstrong
      3. Who Wrote the Bible ? by Richard Elliott Friedman
      4. The Unauthorized Version: Truth and Fiction in the Bible by Robin Lane Fox
      5. A Short History of Christianity by Martin E. Marty

  4. I love the way you include related books in all of your reviews – it makes me add so much to my TBR pile. I’ll be interested to hear yours thoughts on . It seems like that will be a great contrast to this book.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s