The sum is not greater than its parts.

Perhaps it was its provocative title that made me want to grab this book when I saw it sitting there with the other newly arrived books at my public library. Or perhaps I was intrigued by the idea of reading something on the “War of Terror” written from a foreign perspective. Or maybe after reading a number of fictional works I was finally in the mood for a bit of nonfiction. Who knows. However, after reading Loretta Napoleoni’s Terrorism and the Economy: How the War on Terror is Bankrupting the World I can confidently tell you that while most of her recent book is quite fascinating, overall she never quite achieves her ultimate objective-making a convincing case that America’s War on Terror was chiefly responsible for the global economic collapse.

While Napoleoni does a fine job portraying the international economy as a fragile house of cards, especially as it shaped the destinies of the three desperate cities of London, Las Vegas and Dubai, her attempts to show how America’s Patriot Act and it attempts to restrict the international flow of US dollars initiated a cascade of factors which lead to the economic collapse and the resulting “credit crunch” falls just a bit short. In addition, while I have no beef with her leftist sentiments, her hints of a possible Bush Administration conspiracy leading to the 9-11 attacks casts a slight tarnish to her otherwise insightful analysis of America’s reckless economic and political undertakings. In short, don’t attribute to some grand conspiracy theory what you should really blame on incompetence and organizational hubris.

It looks like Napoleoni is the author of a host of books dealing with international economics and related subjects. In the future I hope to read a few of her fine books. Regrettably, this is not one of them.

Advertisements

3 Comments

Filed under Uncategorized

3 responses to “The sum is not greater than its parts.

  1. Eva

    >>In addition, while I have no beef with her leftist sentiments, her hints of a possible Bush Administration conspiracy leading to the 9-11 attacks casts a slight tarnish to her otherwise insightful analysis of America’s reckless economic and political undertakings.

    I feel the same way sometimes when I’m reading international relations stuff. 🙂

  2. “making a convincing case that America’s War on Terror was chiefly responsible for the global economic collapse” seems like a very hard statement to back up. I also wouldn’t like the conspiracy theories. But I do think that if I would’ve come across it in the library I would be tempted to pick it up as well! It’s a shame it’s not as good as you’d hoped.

    Thank you for your comment btw. I’m browsing through your blog now and it looks like you read a lot of interesting books, so I’m going to stick around if you don’t mind :-).

  3. BobbyD

    MC~

    Was Jonz’n all weekend! Sounds like I won’t be reading your latest book…

    Still working on The Reading Chair concept and the ‘First Four Reviews’.

    Carry On Brother!

    RMD

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s